We've already made the case in our sunrise vs sunset guide that this beach's real show happens at the end of the day, not the beginning. There's one more reason for that, and it's genuinely strange: for a second or two, right as the sun slips below the water, the top edge can flash green. It's not an old fisherman's tale — NASA confirms it's a real optical effect, and a Getty Images photo taken specifically at Siesta Key has been used by Space.com to illustrate exactly this phenomenon.
What's actually happening
Earth's atmosphere bends light the same way a glass prism does, splitting it into its component colors. Green light bends slightly more than red, so as the sun's disc drops below the horizon, the green wavelength is the last color still visible at that top edge — for a second or two, before it's gone too. It's not a trick of the eyes or a coincidence of light pollution, it's straightforward physics, just physics that needs very specific conditions to actually become visible.
How to actually try for it
Watch the very top of the sun continuously during the last 15 to 20 seconds before it fully disappears — don't stare at the full disc the whole time, just the upper rim as it gets thin. The flash itself lasts one to two seconds at most, easy to miss if you're looking away or fumbling with a camera at the wrong moment. Clear, dry evenings — often after a cold front passes through in cooler months — tend to be better odds than a typical hazy summer sunset.
Don't expect it every time
This isn't a nightly guarantee, and going in expecting one every sunset is the fastest way to be disappointed. Think of it the same way we framed the bioluminescent waves — a real, documented thing that happens here, worth watching for on a clear evening, but not something you can schedule.
If you're already timing an evening around the Sunday drum circle or just watching the sunset, keep your eyes on that top rim in the final seconds — it costs nothing extra to look, and on the right night, it's one of the odder things you'll see on a beach vacation.
Keep planning